Historical Context: Japan’s Easy Money and the Carry Trade Boom (2023–Early 2024)
For years, Japan’s ultra-loose monetary policy made the yen the world’s cheapest funding currency. The Bank of Japan (BOJ) kept interest rates near or below zero for over a decade, even as other central banks hiked rates to fight inflation. By 2022–2023, this divergence was extreme: while the U.S. Federal Reserve and European Central Bank pushed rates upward, the BOJ was still capping yields. The result was a massive yen-funded carry trade – investors borrowed yen at negligible cost and poured it into higher-yield assets abroad (U.S. stocks and bonds, emerging-market debt, etc.) to “pocket” the rate differential. Japan’s yen had long been a “free money” engine for global markets, fueling risk-taking worldwide.
Yen weakness and booming carry trades
The flood of outbound yen helped weaken Japan’s currency to multi-decade lows. Since early 2022 the yen had lost over 20% of its value against the U.S. dollar, prompting Tokyo to intervene repeatedly to prop it up. In fact, the dollar/yen exchange rate hit a 38-year low (yen at ¥161.96 per $1) in July 2024. This cheap yen supercharged carry trades: by mid-2024, hedge funds and speculators amassed the largest short-yen positions in 17 years.
Japan’s cumulative current account surpluses meant its investors held $3.3 trillion abroad, so the scale of potential unwind was enormous. Going long on global equities (especially U.S. tech) while shorting the yen became a wildly popular strategy. As one analyst quipped, “A popular hedge-fund trade is to borrow yen, acquire dollars and stick it into an asset they think will go up more than the carry”. This worked well as long as the yen steadily depreciated and volatility stayed low – conditions that held through 2023.
Storm clouds gather
By mid-2024, however, conditions were ripe for reversal. Japan’s inflation had ticked up and policymakers began dropping hints about phasing out easy money. In December 2023, market strategists (presciently) warned that if the BOJ tightened policy, “the potential for a reversal of decades of outward flow of capital may be felt by investors worldwide”. Indeed, speculative short-yen bets looked overstretched by July 2024, and Japanese authorities had already intervened with an estimated ¥5 trillion (~$40 billion) of yen-buying that month to halt the currency’s slide. The stage was set: any hawkish move by the BOJ or shock to risk sentiment could trigger an unwinding of the towering yen carry trade.
Summer 2024 – The Unwinding Begins
In late July 2024, the BOJ finally moved. At its July 31 meeting, the BOJ shocked markets with a rate hike, raising its short-term policy rate to 0.25% (up from 0% and the first time above 0.25% since 2008). It also outlined plans to slow its massive bond-buying, effectively ending a decade of quantitative easing. BOJ Governor Kazuo Ueda even signaled this could be the start of a full-fledged tightening cycle, a dramatic policy shift after years of negative rates. The message was clear: Japan was drawing a line under the era of ultra-cheap money.
BOJ’s Pivot and a “Perfect Storm”
This BOJ hawkish turn, coming as U.S. data showed mild cracks (and the Fed was “cautious” about further hikes), set off a perfect storm for the yen carry trade. The yen’s long decline abruptly reversed. Within days, the yen surged sharply: it rocketed from around ¥162 per dollar in mid-July to the mid-¥140s by early August – roughly a 14% appreciation in under a month.
Traders who had borrowed yen now faced a surging liability, erasing the profit calculus of their trades. As one report noted, “The yen is a classic example of where positioning and top-down factors are aligning”. Japan’s rate hike (raising funding costs) and a burst of official yen-buying intervention “ignited the yen’s rally”. Moreover, investors anticipated the U.S.-Japan rate gap would finally start narrowing (with the Fed expected to cut rates in late 2024). In short, the fundamental drivers of the carry trade flipped.
Crucially, the market’s psychology flipped too. What had been a one-way bet against the yen suddenly looked treacherous. Speculative funds rushed to cover their shorts – hedge funds slashed their net short-yen futures position by half in just weeks. By mid-August, funds that had been massively short yen were actually net long for the first time in four years. As UBS strategist James Malcolm estimated, roughly $200 billion of yen carry trades were unwound within a few weeks, potentially only about half of the total carry exposure at its peak.
Market Mayhem: Yen Carry Trade Blow-Up in Early August 2024
Monitors in a Japanese trading room show the Nikkei 225 index plunging on August 5, 2024, as the unwinding of yen-funded trades triggers a historic sell-off.
The chain reaction from the yen’s spike hit global markets with ferocity. The stress culminated in the first days of August 2024, when what began as a currency move morphed into a broad market sell-off. On Monday, August 5, 2024, Japan’s stock market collapsed under the weight of forced unwinding. The Nikkei 225 index nosedived 12.4% in one session, its worst day since the 1987 Black Monday crash. In point terms, it was the largest one-day drop in Nikkei history (over 4,450 points wiped out). The broader TOPIX index likewise plunged about 12% that day– part of a three-day rout that erased 20% of TOPIX’s value. Japanese banking and insurance stocks were hammered (the yen surge implied big investment losses for them), and the Nikkei officially entered bear market territory, down 27% from its July peak.
It wasn’t just Japan. As carry traders dumped assets en masse to repay yen loans, shockwaves spread globally. Key impacts across asset classes included:
Equities
The sell-off radiated outward. The S&P 500 fell nearly 5% over two days in early August, including a 1.8% drop followed by a further 3.0% slide on Aug 5. The MSCI All-Country World Index sank ~3% that day, and the S&P Global Broad Market Index (covering 14,000 stocks) plunged 3.3% – its worst trading day in over two years.
European stocks weren’t spared: Europe’s Euro STOXX 50 fell ~1.7% on Aug 5. Notably, high-flying U.S. tech shares – favorites of the yen-funded trade – saw a sharp pullback; a brief tech slump on July 24 had already wiped out $1 trillion in market cap, foreshadowing the pain to come. As one analyst observed, “investors had leveraged up by borrowing in yen to buy other assets, chiefly U.S. tech stocks… we are basically seeing a mass deleveraging as investors sell assets to fund their losses”.
Volatility & Leverage
Market volatility exploded. The VIX (Wall Street’s “fear index”) spiked above 60 intraday on Aug 5 – levels typically seen only in crises (for context, the VIX hadn’t hit those heights since the 2020 COVID crash). This far exceeded what historical correlations would predict for the size of the S&P drop, underscoring the amplifying role of forced deleveraging.
In Japan, the Nikkei Volatility Index likewise surged to crisis-era highs. Essentially, the unwinding carry trades acted like a margin call on the whole market. Funds scrambled to meet margin by selling whatever they could – a classic feedback loop. Global hedge fund leverage had been building up into the summer, which meant more fuel for a fire-sale once margins were triggered.
Currencies (FX)
The yen’s sharp appreciation was the epicenter of the storm. By Aug 5, the yen was around ¥143 per USD – up over 10% in a matter of weeks. Other currencies associated with carry trades saw ripple effects. For example, emerging-market and commodity currencies (which investors had bought using yen) came under pressure as positions unwound. The Australian dollar, Mexican peso, and others that had been buoyed by carry trade inflows weakened in late July/August. Even the Swiss franc (another low-yield funding currency) saw volatility.
In short, the “yen-funded” trade reversal yanked capital out of higher-yield FX, causing mini-shocks in those markets. Still, the yen’s move was the most extreme – it went from 2024’s worst-performing G10 currency to its best performer in July (a 7% gain). This kind of abrupt FX reversal echoed past episodes like 1998 and 2008 when yen carry trades imploded and the yen jumped ~20% in weeks.
Bonds
Initially, the turmoil sparked a bid for safe-haven government bonds (U.S. Treasuries, German Bunds, etc.), potentially as investors fled equities. There were reports of Japanese investors selling foreign bonds to repatriate funds, which could put upward pressure on overseas yields longer-term. In the immediate stress period, U.S. Treasury yields actually dipped then bounced – by the end of that volatile week, the 10-year Treasury yield had risen about 14 basis points to ~3.94%.
This rise may reflect the market’s complex interpretation: the scare fueled recession fears (bullish for bonds), but also many traders closed yen-funded bond positions. Notably, Japanese government bond yields climbed as the BOJ’s hike took effect; the overnight call rate in Japan was now positive, and 10-year JGB yields, which had been capped at 0.5%, were freed to rise toward 0.6–0.7%. Japan’s shift removed a suppressing force on global yields. In essence, the carry trade unwind hinted that global borrowing costs might finally be moving higher in a sustained way as Japan’s decades-long yield suppression faded.
Commodities
Risk-off sentiment weighed on cyclical commodities – for example, oil prices and industrial metals faltered in early August on fears that a surging yen and wobbling stock markets signaled weaker global growth ahead. On the flip side, traditional safe havens like gold saw interest: gold prices dipped only slightly during the peak chaos (down just ~1% on Aug 5), outperforming risk assets.
In fact, gold held its value far better than equities or crypto during the sell-off, underscoring its “haven” status. Some observers noted that the yen’s rebound, by tightening financial conditions, could be deflationary globally – an environment where gold often shines if real yields are contained. Overall commodity impacts were mixed, but the broader trend of tightening liquidity suggested potential headwinds for commodities that had benefited from plentiful cheap capital.
Crypto
The crypto market was not immune to the carry trade carnage – if anything, it reacted with high beta. Major cryptocurrencies plunged in tandem with stocks. Bitcoin, which had been hovering near $55,000 in late July 2024, cratered almost 17% intraday on Aug 5, briefly dipping below $50k for the first time in months. It recovered some losses but still closed the day down ~8%. The broader Bloomberg Galaxy Crypto Index plummeted as much as 17.5%.
This episode was telling: it challenged the notion of Bitcoin as “digital gold.” Unlike gold’s relative stability, crypto behaved like a risk-on asset, amplifying the stock sell-off. Analysts at Citi pointed out that despite Bitcoin’s limited supply similar to gold, it failed to serve as a reliable store of value during market stress. In short, the carry trade unwind reaffirmed that crypto markets are deeply intertwined with global liquidity conditions – when leverage and risk appetite tumble, so do Bitcoin and its peers.
At the eye of the storm was Japan.
The sheer magnitude of the moves on Aug 5 was almost unprecedented for a developed market. The Nikkei’s 12% plunge that day wiped out ¥113 trillion in market value (roughly $790 billion) and erased its gains for the entire year. It was “a record-breaking drop” by any measure.
Tokyo’s Finance Ministry watched with “grave concern” and admitted it was hard to pinpoint a single cause. Most experts, however, agreed that the yen carry trade implosion was a prime culprit – the rapid yen spike put “downward pressure on Japanese equities” and “drove an unwind of a major carry trade”, as one market analyst noted. In the U.S., the brief meltdown was dubbed a “mini-crash”; by the next day, headlines like “How Japan’s Yen Carry Trade Crashed Global Markets” were making the rounds, drawing parallels to past contagion episodes..
Containment and Aftershocks: Stabilization, Policy Responses, and Ongoing Repercussions
Remarkably, the August turmoil was sharp but short-lived – at least initially. By the end of that week (Aug 9, 2024), markets had stabilized and even rebounded. The S&P 500 recovered all its early-August losses by week’s end, and Japan’s TOPIX clawed back most (though not all) of its drop.
The VIX quickly receded from panic levels above 60 down to more normal (if still elevated) levels. In other words, there was no sustained global financial crisis – more a violent tremor that subsided once the bulk of leveraged positions were shaken out. Analysts noted that “markets then stabilised almost as quickly” as they had sold off. This swift recovery suggested that fundamental contagion was limited; what we witnessed was largely a positioning purge and margin-driven volatility, rather than a collapse of economic fundamentals.
The Bank of Japan
Policymakers took note and took care. The Bank of Japan, having inadvertently triggered chaos with its hawkish surprise, moved to soothe nerves. In the days following the sell-off, BOJ officials walked back some of their aggressive tone. Notably, BOJ Deputy Governor Shinichi Uchida pledged to “refrain from further rate hikes amid market instability,” effectively pausing tightening to ensure financial stability.
This assurance of a gentler approach helped cap the yen’s rapid rise (the yen actually eased back from its early-August highs, settling into the mid-¥140s per USD). In the U.S., the Federal Reserve monitored the situation; Fed officials noted the spike in volatility but, seeing markets normalize, stuck to their data-dependent stance. (In fact, the carry trade episode arguably reinforced expectations that the Fed’s next move would be a rate cut – U.S. futures markets had already been pricing Fed rate reductions for late 2024).
BOJ Policy
Ironically, the more the Fed eases while BOJ tightens, the more the yen could strengthen, potentially prolonging the unwind of carry trades. It’s a dynamic not lost on investors: one August 2024 report cautioned that the unwinding was likely only “halfway done,” and that expected Fed rate cuts could “further exacerbate the carry trade unwind” by eroding the dollar’s yield advantage.
Hedge funds and institutions have since been grappling with the new reality. By late August 2024, as calm returned, some opportunistic funds tiptoed back into carry trades – albeit at lower leverage. Bloomberg reported that the very same “carry trade that blew up markets” was attracting hedge funds again by mid-August, as yen shorts crept back up once volatility subsided (a testament to how profitable the trade can be, and perhaps how short memories can be).
But the easy-money environment that nurtured those trades has fundamentally changed. Global strategists now describe the summer of 2024 as a pivot point signaling the end of an era. As a State Street report put it, “late July and early August 2024, the Japanese equity market hit unexpected turbulence” that highlighted a regime shift. The BOJ’s policy U-turn means the world’s last source of near-free liquidity is drying up. In practical terms, that implies higher costs of capital and potentially lower risk appetite across the board moving forward.
What are the broader implications for major economies? We can already discern several:
United States
The yen carry trade unwind may herald the end of the “imported” easy money that had bolstered U.S. asset prices. Japanese investors have been huge buyers of U.S. Treasuries and stocks over the years (thanks to better yields abroad), but now capital could start flowing back to Japan as its rates rise. Indeed, 2024 saw Japanese funds trimming foreign bond holdings – a factor that some believe contributed to higher U.S. long-term yields in the latter half of the year.
The U.S. equity market, which was buoyed by global liquidity, might face valuation headwinds if one source of that liquidity retrenches. On the flip side, a stronger yen and weaker dollar could improve U.S. trade competitiveness slightly and ease import price pressures. The Fed will weigh these global factors in its policy: turmoil abroad can act like a rate hike at home by tightening financial conditions. While the August episode alone didn’t push the Fed off course, it underscored how vulnerable highly leveraged strategies can destabilize U.S. markets. American regulators and funds are now on guard for similar unwinds (e.g. dollar-funded carry trades) especially as the Fed contemplates rate cuts. In short, the U.S. faces a new world where it can’t rely on Japan’s surplus capital as freely – a potential inflection point for everything from Treasury demand to tech stock flows.
Europe
Europe felt the ripple mainly via market sentiment and some currency adjustments. European stocks had a modest correction during the August shock (Euro STOXX down ~5% over the course of that week). More significantly, European bond markets are also exposed to Japanese flows – e.g. Japanese insurers and pensions have large positions in Eurozone bonds. As Japanese yields rise, Europe could see outflows, putting pressure on bond prices (and upward pressure on yields).
The European Central Bank was already in tightening mode in 2024; the BOJ’s pivot effectively means no G7 central bank is flooding markets with liquidity anymore, reinforcing the global tightening cycle. The euro gained slightly against a falling dollar during the carry unwind, since the yen’s surge dragged other currencies upward relative to USD. That added strength to the euro at a time when Europe’s economy was struggling, a headache for the ECB. Looking ahead, Europe will need to navigate this macro realignment by relying more on domestic investors – one less big buyer (Japan) in the mix. European officials, like their U.S. counterparts, are now keenly aware that a volatility jolt can emanate from faraway currency funding stresses and quickly spread to Frankfurt or Paris. The carry trade saga thus bolsters arguments in Europe for completing banking union and bolstering market resilience against global shocks.
Japan
For Japan itself, the consequences are double-edged. The unwinding of the yen carry trade was painful for Japanese equities in the short run (a historic crash followed by a rapid rebound). But it was also evidence that Japan is – at long last – escaping its deflationary, zero-rate trap. Inflation entrenched around 2% and rising wages gave the BOJ confidence to hike in 2024, marking the end of an era of negative rates. A stronger yen, while it hurts exporters, improves Japanese consumers’ purchasing power by making imports (energy, food) cheaper – an important benefit with global inflation still elevated.
The government in Tokyo must now manage a delicate transition:
Higher rates will significantly increase debt service costs on Japan’s massive public debt, and authorities will remain vigilant against excessive yen spikes (indeed, they showed willingness to intervene to smooth volatility). However, a moderate yen appreciation aligns with BOJ’s goals of curbing import-price inflation. Another domestic positive: Japanese households and institutions may redirect some of the trillions parked abroad back into the local economy, spurring domestic investment. There are signs of this shift – for instance, Japanese banks started offering slightly higher deposit rates, and citizens are moving savings into local stocks and bonds in search of yield.
The summer carry-trade blow-up was a wake-up call to Japan Inc. that the “free ride” of a perpetually weak yen is over. In the long run, a more balanced global role – with Japan exporting capital less freely – could make Japan’s markets more self-reliant and corporate sector more focused on fundamentals (rather than just benefitting from currency cheapness). As 2025 unfolds, Japan appears to be entering a new monetary regime, one which Prime Minister Fumio Kishida’s administration hopes will be accompanied by structural reforms and a more vibrant domestic economy.
China and Emerging Markets
While the yen carry trade centers on Japan, its unwinding is part of a broader transition impacting China and other emerging economies. China, in 2024, was navigating its own challenges (property sector stress, a slowing economy) and easing policy to support growth. A rapidly strengthening yen/dollar (i.e. weakening dollar) can affect China’s currency management – indeed, if the dollar softens as Fed rates peak, the Chinese yuan may stabilize or strengthen, which Beijing might welcome to ease import costs. However, a key indirect effect is via global liquidity: the end of ultra-cheap yen funding and higher global rates reduce the tide of money that often found its way into emerging markets. Countries like India, Indonesia, Brazil, and Turkey – which previously saw capital inflows partly financed by cheap yen or euro borrowing – could face more volatile capital flows or outflows.
In late 2024, some emerging market central banks actually preemptively raised rates or shored up reserves, mindful that if global investors are forced to unwind carry positions, their currencies and asset markets could be caught in the downdraft. China, with its managed capital account, is less directly exposed to hot money swings, but it is affected by global risk sentiment. The August episode briefly hit Hong Kong and Asia-ex-Japan stocks; for China, which is trying to attract foreign investors, the prospect of a persistently stronger yen and tighter Japanese financial conditions adds competition for capital in Asia.
End of Cheap Money
In a sense, the yen carry trade unwind is one facet of the larger end of the “cheap money” era that fueled rapid investment in emerging markets. Major emerging economies will need to adjust to a world where global investors can no longer borrow at ~0% in Japan to fund bets on higher yields in developing countries. This could mean higher borrowing costs and more emphasis on economic fundamentals to attract investment. It might also encourage regional financial cooperation – for instance, Asian economies have been deepening swap lines and safety nets, aware that volatility from Japan’s policy shift could ricochet through the region.
End of an Era: Lessons and the Road Ahead
The summer 2024 yen carry trade blow-up was more than a one-off bout of turbulence – it was a signal that the easy money era is drawing to a close. For over a decade (and arguably since the 2008 crisis), abundant liquidity from major central banks suppressed volatility and encouraged leverage. Japan was the final holdout in this global shift; its yield curve control and negative rates had for years anchored a low-volatility environment that speculators felt comfortable exploiting.
When that anchor moved, the resulting shock exposed how stretched and interconnected things had become. As the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) observed, this event was “another example of volatility exacerbated by procyclical deleveraging and margin increases”, and it highlighted structural vulnerabilities that policymakers cannot ignore. In simpler terms: when lots of investors are piled into the same trade using borrowed money, the exit – if rushed – gets awfully crowded and disorderly.
Macroeconomic Realignment
Going forward, we are likely in a period of significant macroeconomic realignment. All major central banks are no longer in easing mode simultaneously – a stark contrast to the 2010s. The BOJ’s pivot means global interest rate differentials will start to narrow, especially if the Fed and other central banks begin cutting rates (as cycles turn) while Japan continues a gentle hiking path. Some analysts even posit a coming role reversal in carry trades: with U.S. rates possibly heading down and Japanese rates up, we might see investors borrowing in dollars to invest in other currencies – a “negative carry trade” shift that was unimaginable a few years ago.
Already by late 2024, some hedge funds reportedly began borrowing in U.S. dollars anticipating Fed rate cuts (and a softer dollar). Such developments underscore a new paradigm: the dollar’s reign as the high-yielding currency could be challenged if U.S. yields fall and others rise. The multi-decade pattern of dollar-based carry (where emerging markets borrow cheaply in USD) might morph as well, with implications for global credit markets.
Adapting Investors
Investors and institutions will need to adapt to higher volatility and more discriminate capital. No longer will the tide of nearly free yen automatically lift all boats. We can expect more tactical trading and perhaps shorter-term horizon for carry trades – already, the August 2024 episode showed that once burned, twice shy (at least for a while). Central banks, for their part, are likely to be more cognizant of cross-border feedback loops.
The BOJ will calibrate its next moves carefully, aware that every tweak can reverberate through currency and derivative markets worldwide. The Fed and ECB, when assessing financial stability, will keep an eye on things like yen-funded leverage among global investors. International forums (G20, IMF) have also taken note; questions of coordination may arise if another bout of turmoil hits. (It wouldn’t be shocking if, in a future crisis, central banks consider swap lines or coordinated interventions – for instance, joint efforts to stabilize the yen if disorderly moves threaten global stability.)
Rude Awakening
In summary, the yen carry trade’s blow-up in summer 2024 was a rude awakening that the days of “picking up nickels in front of a steamroller” via easy leverage are ending. It has affected virtually every asset class – from stocks and bonds to commodities and crypto – and forced a rethink among the world’s major economic players. The episode may be most analogous to past inflection points like 1998 (LTCM’s collapse) or 2007, which presaged broader regime changes. While 2024’s jolt was contained, it carries a clear message: investors ignore macro shifts at their peril. Strategies predicated on forever-low volatility and ultra-cheap funding are vulnerable in this new landscape. We are likely entering a phase of more frequent realignments, where capital flows adjust to a post-easy-money reality.
On the bright side, such realignment can bring some benefits: more rational asset pricing, reduced froth in risk-taking, and a return of capital to regions (like Japan) that have long been starved for it. For the savvy market participant, volatility also means opportunity – carry trades aren’t dead, they’re just taking new forms (with new risks) in a world where the cost of money is no longer near zero. As one market strategist remarked after the dust settled, “the key takeaway for investors is that strategies like carry trading are highly sensitive to changes in interest rates and currency values… this episode serves as a reminder of the risks of assuming stability”.
In other words, 2024 taught us that even long-standing “true-blue” trades can unravel suddenly. The yen carry trade’s unravelling is a defining moment – one that likely marks the end of an era of easy money and the beginning of a new macro chapter where vigilance, diversification, and respect for risk are paramount.
Leave A Comment