Baseball fans love to debate everything from the designated hitter to playoff formats, but here’s a topic that that is now getting everyone’s attention – how MLB’s structure has been completely reshaped over the decades. The National League kicked things off in 1876, and when the American League jumped into the mix in 1901, nobody could have predicted how much the game’s competitive landscape would shift over the next century.
Picture this: the game went from 16 teams to 30 teams through what you might call baseball’s growth spurts. Each time the league expanded, it meant reshuffling divisions and rethinking how teams would compete against each other. The 1990s alone brought four new franchises into the fold that changed baseball forever.
Manfred’s got his sights set on picking two expansion cities before he steps down in 2029 and cities are lining up to make their bids. If you’re betting on the future, we’re probably looking at 32 teams by 2030. What makes this story worth telling? These weren’t just administrative moves – they were decisions that completely altered America’s pastime. From the rivalries we love to the playoff races that keep us glued to our screens, realignment shaped it all.
The Early Realignments: 1969 to 1993
Baseball’s biggest shake-up started in 1969, and it changed everything about how we watch the game. Before this moment, both leagues kept things simple – one division each, with pennant winners heading straight to the World Series. No fuss, no complexity. This season brought baseball’s third expansion of the decade, adding four new teams to the mix. Kansas City Royals and Seattle Pilots joined the American League, while the Montreal Expos and San Diego Padres landed in the National League. This bump to 24 teams total meant the old format had to go.
For the first time ever, both leagues split into East and West divisions with six teams each. The American League kept it straightforward – pure geography. The National League? Well, that’s where things got interesting. The Chicago Cubs and St. Louis Cardinals threw their weight around, demanding spots in the Eastern Division alongside the Mets and Phillies. The result was pretty wild – Atlanta and Cincinnati ended up in the Western Division despite being nowhere near the west coast. Teams still played 162 games, but now it was 18 against division rivals and 12 against the other division. The scheduling headaches alone must have been brutal.
1977: Blue Jays & Mariners join
Eight years later, MLB expanded again with Toronto Blue Jays and Seattle Mariners joining the American League. This brought the total to 26 teams. Seattle’s addition was actually a comeback story – the Pilots had packed up and moved to Milwaukee back in 1970. Toronto’s ownership group paid approximately CAD $7 million for their franchise, while Seattle’s group – which included actor Danny Kaye, believe it or not – shelled out $6.5 million. The expansion draft on November 5, 1976 helped both teams build their rosters from scratch.
1993: Rockies & Marlins added
After a 16-year break from expansion, baseball welcomed the Colorado Rockies and Florida Marlins to the National League in 1993. This wasn’t some spur-of-the-moment decision – it came from agreements hammered out in the 1985 collective bargaining talks.
The MLB started with ten potential cities before narrowing it down to six finalists. Denver and Miami got the official thumbs up on July 5, 1991. H. Wayne Huizenga paid the entire $95 million franchise fee for the Marlins – a hefty sum that showed how much the game had grown. The 1993 expansion draft made history as the first time both leagues had to make players available. Colorado grabbed pitcher David Nied first overall, while Florida went with outfielder Nigel Wilson. Not exactly household names, but that’s expansion draft reality for you.
The 1994 Shift & Its Aftermath
The realignment that had the biggest impact on modern baseball appears to be 1994. MLB realignment that year created the structure we know today, but the timing couldn’t have been worse in what was one of the darkest chapters in baseball history. The players’ strike began on August 12, 1994, and everything fell apart. After 34 days of back-and-forth, acting commissioner Bud Selig made the call nobody wanted to hear – season’s over. For the first time since 1904, no World Series champion. Think about that for a moment. The Montreal Expos had the best record in baseball at 74-40 when the strike hit. Many point to this moment as the beginning of the end for the Expos, who eventually packed up for Washington D.C.
The Three-Division Revolution & Wild Card
After 25 years of the East-West setup, baseball decided it was time for something completely different. The three-division alignment – East, Central, and West in both leagues . This wasn’t just shuffling deck chairs; it was the first major structural change since the Blue Jays and Mariners joined in 1977. Smaller divisions meant more teams had realistic playoff shots, and fans in certain places could actually believe their teams had a chance late into September.
Here’s what many modern baseball fans may not know. The Wild Card playoff spot wasn’t just an add-on – it completely changed how teams approached the season. Suddenly, you didn’t need to win your division to make the postseason. One wild card from each league expanded the field from four to eight teams total. The format had teams facing division winners with the best records, unless they came from the same division. Sounds straightforward enough, right? Well, baseball fans never got to see how it played out that first year.
2000s: Full merger of AL and NL operations
Baseball stepped into the new millennium and decided it was time to stop pretending the American and National Leagues were separate entities. To be fair, this integration made sense – but it also ended nearly a century of tradition. The American and National Leagues officially merged into a single organization in 2000. One league, one commissioner, one set of rules. The days of separate league presidents actually running their own shows were over. Both leagues kept honorary presidents for ceremonial roles, which honestly feels like giving someone a participation trophy. The umpire situation changed completely too. Instead of AL and NL umps calling different strike zones, the new system created integrated crews with at least one umpire from each league. They even standardized the uniforms – blue shirts and gray pants for everyone.
2013: Astros move to AL West
Now this was a bold move. MLB approved the Houston Astros‘ relocation from the NL Central to the AL West in 2011. Finally, 15 teams per league with three divisions of five teams each. Perfect balance, right? Well, not everyone was thrilled. Lance Berkman called it “a travesty” for the historically National League franchise. I get it – the Astros had been NL since 1962. But here’s the thing: it created a natural rivalry with the Texas Rangers, and honestly, Texas needed all the baseball drama it could get.
Interleague play becomes standard
Remember when interleague play was this special novelty that happened a few times a year? Those days are long gone. With uneven leagues after 2013, interleague play became necessary throughout the season. MLB implemented a balanced schedule in 2023 where all 30 teams play each other annually. Teams now play 46 interleague games instead of 16-20.
I won’t sugarcoat this – some traditional rivalries took a hit. But the balanced schedule allows teams within divisions to have 91% of games in common, which creates fairer competition for playoff spots. You can’t argue with that logic. The future looks even more dramatic. Commissioner Manfred has proposed further geographic realignment, potentially creating east/west conferences rather than leagues. We might be looking at the end of AL vs. NL as we know it. Whether that’s progress or sacrilege depends on who you ask.
The Future Game Plan
Baseball’s next chapter could look completely different from anything we’ve seen before. We’re talking about potentially tearing down over a century of tradition and rebuilding from scratch. The most radical idea floating around? Scrapping the American and National Leagues entirely for Eastern and Western Conferences. Think NBA or NHL structure applied to baseball. Jim Bowden, who knows a thing or two about baseball operations, threw out a fascinating model in 2023. Picture eight divisions with four teams each, all organized by geography.
Now here’s where fans are using their imagination – creating graphics for a division featuring the Yankees, Mets, Red Sox, and Phillies. Of course, traditionalists might not love seeing historic rivalries get shuffled around. To be fair, any of these changes would face massive resistance from fans who’ve grown up with the current system. But from a competitive and financial standpoint? The numbers don’t lie – geographic realignment just makes more sense in 2024.
Looking Into the Crystal Ball
Predicting MLB’s next move isn’t exactly rocket science. There maybe a timeline for two expansion cities before 2029, but many dominoes have to fall first. The whole geographic realignment piece depends on it. Scrapping the American and National Leagues entirely would be the boldest move since the merger of operations in 2000. Eastern and Western Conferences make sense on paper – less travel, better TV windows, more logical rivalries.
But let’s be honest here. Some changes stick, others don’t. The designated hitter took decades to reach the National League. Wild Card slots expanded from one to two per league. Baseball adapts, but it adapts slowly, with respect for its own history. Kids today can’t imagine baseball without interleague play or Wild Card races. Our grandparents couldn’t imagine divisions at all.
That’s the beauty of this sport – it honors its past while embracing its future. Whether we end up with Eastern and Western Conferences or some completely different structure nobody’s thought of yet, one thing’s certain: baseball will keep evolving. The game that survived two World Wars, multiple strikes, and countless other challenges isn’t going anywhere. The next chapter of realignment is going to be written in the next few years, and we get front-row seats to watch it unfold.
Leave A Comment